Where experts disagree
Of the 1,983 items Cited tracks, 46 have credentialed experts publicly on both sides — 48 experts in total. Ranked by how genuinely contested each one is. Every count links to the exact quote, episode, and timestamp it came from.
How this ranking works
Two different things are being counted. The for / against numbers count takes — individual recommendations, so an expert who has made the same case across four episodes is counted four times. The endorsed by / cautioned by names count experts. The two will rarely match, and an expert whose own takes are evenly split on an item appears in neither list.
Each item scores on three things: the size of the minority position (one dissenting voice against twelve is weaker evidence of a real split than five against seven), how evenly split the two camps are, and how many experts weighed in at all. An item with everyone on one side scores zero and never appears here. So does an item only one expert has ever mentioned — a single voice cannot disagree with the field.
The counts are derived mechanically from extracted recommendations. Cited does not decide who is right, and nothing here is a rating of the item. A crowded "avoid" column means several experts said avoid, not that avoiding is correct. Extraction is automated and not editorially verified — see our methodology and how to flag an error.