The index · Disagreements

Where experts disagree

Of the 1,983 items Cited tracks, 46 have credentialed experts publicly on both sides — 48 experts in total. Ranked by how genuinely contested each one is. Every count links to the exact quote, episode, and timestamp it came from.

1
Caffeine supplement ◆ Experts divided
10 for
9 against takes
Endorsed byAndrew Huberman, Layne Norton, Michael Ormsbee, Rhonda Patrick +1 more
Cautioned byAndy Galpin, Matt Walker, Rangan Chatterjee, Satchin Panda
11 experts
22 takes total
2
Melatonin supplement ◆ Experts divided
13 for
8 against takes
Endorsed byLayne Norton, Matt Walker, Steven Gundry
Cautioned byAndrew Huberman
5 experts
21 takes total
3
Collagen supplement ▼ Broad caution
3 for
4 against takes
Endorsed byBen Greenfield, Chris Masterjohn, Michael Ormsbee
Cautioned byLayne Norton, Max Lugavere, Rhonda Patrick, Steven Gundry
7 experts
7 takes total
4
Ketogenic diet practice ◆ Experts divided
3 for
3 against takes
Endorsed byDavid Perlmutter, Mark Hyman
Cautioned byMichael Greger, Valter Longo
5 experts
7 takes total
5
Vitamin D supplement ▲ Mostly endorse
14 for
2 against takes
Endorsed byAndrew Huberman, Andy Galpin, Ben Greenfield, Bryan Johnson +8 more
Cautioned byTim Spector
15 experts
18 takes total
6
BPC-157 supplement ◆ Experts divided
3 for
2 against takes
Endorsed byAbud Bakri, Andrew Huberman
Cautioned byTerry Simpson
4 experts
6 takes total
7
Branched chain amino acids supplement ▼ Broad caution
2 for
3 against takes
Endorsed byJim Stoppani, Rhonda Patrick
Cautioned byLayne Norton, Peter Attia
4 experts
5 takes total
8
Statins supplement ◆ Experts divided
2 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byLayne Norton, Navdeep Chandel
Cautioned byPeter Attia
6 experts
6 takes total
9
Nicotinamide riboside (NR) supplement ◆ Experts divided
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byBryan Johnson
Cautioned byPeter Attia
3 experts
3 takes total
10
Omega-3 fatty acids supplement ▲ Strong endorse
16 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byAndy Galpin, Ben Greenfield, Dave Asprey, Mark Hyman +8 more
Cautioned byTerry Simpson
14 experts
18 takes total
11
Creatine supplement ▲ Strong endorse
26 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byAndrew Huberman, Andy Galpin, Dave Asprey, Jim Stoppani +8 more
Cautioned byTim Spector
14 experts
28 takes total
12
GLP-1 agonists supplement ▲ Mostly endorse
4 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byAbud Bakri, Anna Lembke, Fran Haydanek, Mark Hyman
Cautioned byMark Sisson
7 experts
7 takes total
13
Ashwagandha supplement ▲ Strong endorse
7 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byAndrew Huberman, Andy Galpin, Daniel Amen, Layne Norton +2 more
Cautioned byHirsh Trivedi
7 experts
8 takes total
14
Metformin supplement ▲ Mostly endorse
5 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byBryan Johnson, David Sinclair, Navdeep Chandel, Peter Attia
Cautioned byTim Ferriss
6 experts
9 takes total
15
Electrolytes supplement ▲ Strong endorse
5 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byDave Asprey, Gary Brecka, Peter Attia, Rhonda Patrick +1 more
Cautioned byLayne Norton
6 experts
6 takes total
16
Coenzyme Q10 supplement ▲ Strong endorse
4 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byChris Masterjohn, Mark Hyman, Mary Claire Haver, Steven Gundry
Cautioned byNavdeep Chandel
5 experts
5 takes total
17
Iron supplement ▲ Strong endorse
4 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byChris Masterjohn, Layne Norton, Mark Hyman, Stacy Sims
Cautioned byDavid Sinclair
5 experts
5 takes total
18
Alcohol avoidance practice ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byRhonda Patrick
Cautioned byTerry Simpson
2 experts
2 takes total
19
Ayahuasca supplement ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byGabor Maté
Cautioned byTim Ferriss
2 experts
2 takes total
20
Calorie counting practice ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byDaniel Amen
Cautioned byJason Fung
2 experts
2 takes total
21
Fermentable fiber concept ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byFederica Amati
Cautioned byMark Hyman
2 experts
2 takes total
22
Fructose food ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byRhonda Patrick
Cautioned byPeter Attia
2 experts
2 takes total
23
Fruit food ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byMichael Greger
Cautioned bySteven Gundry
2 experts
2 takes total
24
Honey food ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byRoss Edgley
Cautioned byMichael Greger
2 experts
2 takes total
25
Insoluble fiber food ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byPeter Attia
Cautioned bySteven Gundry
2 experts
2 takes total
26
L-carnitine supplement ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byAndrew Huberman
Cautioned byNavdeep Chandel
2 experts
2 takes total
27
Linoleic acid food ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byLayne Norton
Cautioned byTom Brenna
2 experts
2 takes total
28
Milk thistle supplement ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byGary Brecka
Cautioned byHirsh Trivedi
2 experts
2 takes total
29
Resveratrol supplement ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byDavid Sinclair
Cautioned byPeter Attia
2 experts
2 takes total
30
Seed oils food ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byLayne Norton
Cautioned byVani Hari
2 experts
2 takes total
31
Urolithin A supplement ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byTim Ferriss
Cautioned byNavdeep Chandel
2 experts
2 takes total
32
Vitamin B3 (Niacin) supplement ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byRhonda Patrick
Cautioned byDavid Sinclair
2 experts
2 takes total
33
VO2 max concept ▼ Broad caution
1 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byLayne Norton
Cautioned byMark Sisson
2 experts
2 takes total
34
Mouth taping practice ▲ Strong endorse
5 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byAndrew Huberman, James Nestor, Steven Gundry, Tim Spector
Cautioned byPatrick McKeown
5 experts
6 takes total
35
Acetaminophen supplement ▼ Broad caution
1 for
2 against takes
Endorsed byPeter Attia
Cautioned byGary Brecka, Rhonda Patrick
3 experts
4 takes total
36
Creatine HCL supplement ▼ Broad caution
1 for
2 against takes
Endorsed byJim Stoppani
Cautioned byLayne Norton
3 experts
4 takes total
37
Avoiding screens before bed practice ▼ Broad caution
1 for
2 against takes
Endorsed byLayne Norton
Cautioned byMel Robbins, Patrick McKeown
3 experts
3 takes total
38
Berberine supplement ◆ Experts divided
2 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byDavid Sinclair, Gary Brecka
Cautioned byNavdeep Chandel
3 experts
3 takes total
39
Dark chocolate food ◆ Experts divided
2 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byDavid Perlmutter, William Li
Cautioned byRangan Chatterjee
3 experts
3 takes total
40
Nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN) supplement ▲ Strong endorse
4 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byAndrew Huberman, Bryan Johnson, David Sinclair
Cautioned byPeter Attia
4 experts
5 takes total
41
Glycine supplement ▲ Strong endorse
9 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byAndrew Huberman, Chris Masterjohn, Mark Hyman, Matt Walker +1 more
5 experts
10 takes total
42
Avoid bright light at night practice ▲ Strong endorse
6 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byAndrew Huberman, Mark Hyman, Matt Walker, Rhonda Patrick
4 experts
7 takes total
43
Probiotics supplement ◆ Experts divided
3 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byRhonda Patrick, Will Bulsiewicz
3 experts
4 takes total
44
Glutamine supplement ◆ Experts divided
2 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byRoss Edgley
2 experts
3 takes total
45
Nattokinase supplement ◆ Experts divided
3 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byAndrew Huberman
Cautioned byTerry Simpson
2 experts
4 takes total
46
Time-restricted eating practice ◆ Experts divided
3 for
1 against takes
Endorsed byDavid Sinclair, Peter Attia
2 experts
4 takes total

How this ranking works

Two different things are being counted. The for / against numbers count takes — individual recommendations, so an expert who has made the same case across four episodes is counted four times. The endorsed by / cautioned by names count experts. The two will rarely match, and an expert whose own takes are evenly split on an item appears in neither list.

Each item scores on three things: the size of the minority position (one dissenting voice against twelve is weaker evidence of a real split than five against seven), how evenly split the two camps are, and how many experts weighed in at all. An item with everyone on one side scores zero and never appears here. So does an item only one expert has ever mentioned — a single voice cannot disagree with the field.

The counts are derived mechanically from extracted recommendations. Cited does not decide who is right, and nothing here is a rating of the item. A crowded "avoid" column means several experts said avoid, not that avoiding is correct. Extraction is automated and not editorially verified — see our methodology and how to flag an error.