#416 ‒ The science of mitochondria: their role in health, aging, and disease, and what the evidence says about drugs and supplements aimed at improving their function | Navdeep Chandel, Ph.D.
Auto-extracted preview. These recommendations were transcribed and classified from the episode audio. Timestamps link to the source; classifications are not yet editorially verified.
Recommendations from this episode
In transcript order-
People in selenium-deficient regions (Northern New Zealand, Sweden, Finland) may benefit from supplementation to support GPX4 function against lipid peroxides.
“Some countries may have low selenium, so they may want to take selenium
CaveatsUS diet is already high in seleniumCertaintyhedgedrecommendation -
Organic (prompted)
Chandel warns against high-dose antioxidant supplementation: most people have sufficient capacity, and excessive intake may interfere with needed H2O2 signaling (e.g., impairing immune function, worsening some cancers).
“the antioxidant trials in those cases... made it worse
CaveatsSelenium or vitamin C deficiency correction may still be warranted in deficient populationsCertaintyexplicitmild caution -
Chandel mentions topical vitamin C supports skin collagen prolyl hydroxylases (alpha-KG dioxygenases) keeping skin healthy with age.
“the vitamin C that people like to put on their skin... collagen prolyl hydroxylases
Certaintyhedgedoffhand mention -
Attia uses a cycling test holding lactate below 2 mmol/L to assess mitochondrial function; implies training in this zone to build mitochondrial capacity.
“as long as lactate is below 2 millimole... this person is maximizing mitochondrial capacity
DosageSteady-state exercise with blood lactate maintained below 2 mmol/LCertaintyexplicitrecommendation -
Organic (prompted) In a protocol
Chandel suggests citrulline supplementation for those on metformin, since metformin lowers blood citrulline, potentially impairing vasodilation and exercise response.
“if you're taking metformin, take citrulline
CaveatsMechanism via NO/vasodilation is speculativeCertaintyhedgedrecommendation -
In a protocol
Chandel recommends B12 supplementation for those on metformin because metformin reduces B12 absorption in the gut.
“B12 levels go down with metformin. So people should take B12
Certaintyexplicitrecommendation -
In a protocol
Chandel suggests using a CGM during a metformin trial to see if postprandial glucose spikes are being blunted.
“You have a glucose monitor or you do it for three months
DosageUse for ~3 months to assess metformin's effect on glucose spikesCertaintyhedgedrecommendation -
Alternative
If considering berberine for glucose lowering, Chandel suggests just taking metformin instead—they appear to act via the same complex I mechanism, and metformin is cheaper and regulated.
“metformin is probably cheaper than berberine and is regulated. Use metformin
Certaintyexplicitmild caution -
Organic (prompted)
Chandel is unconvinced by urolithin A for general use—mechanism (mitophagy) target is unclear and bioavailability is poor; possible niche use in anti-tumor immunity.
“I don't see any data... not enough to make me say let's use that
CaveatsRapidly glucuronidated in liver; free urolithin barely detectable in plasmaCertaintyhedgedmild caution -
Organic (prompted)
Chandel sees mechanistic promise in alpha-ketoglutarate for maintaining DNA demethylase activity, but questions if endogenous levels are ever rate-limiting; potential niche uses like colitis or gut health.
“I like that one a lot and I study it myself
CaveatsCells only need ~100 micromolar; unclear if supplementation raises levels where limitingCertaintyspeculativeoffhand mention -
Organic (prompted) In a protocol
Chandel considers metformin before meals to blunt postprandial glucose spikes in pre-diabetic or insulin-resistant people; weak case for insulin-sensitive individuals.
“metformin abrogates that [glucose spike]... 30 minutes before a meal
DosageTake ~30 minutes before mealsCaveatsCan cause B12 deficiency and lower citrulline; may blunt exercise-induced VO2max/hypertrophy gainsCertaintyhedgedrecommendation -
Organic (prompted)
Chandel doubts carnitine supplementation is useful since most people—including non-meat-eaters—get enough endogenously to run fatty acid oxidation.
“even people who don't eat meat... probably get sufficient amount
Certaintyhedgedmild caution -
Organic (prompted)
CoQ10 may have a rationale in statin users with muscle symptoms but trials have been unimpressive; not recommended for general health in people with adequate CoQ10 levels.
“for normal health. No, you have enough coq
CaveatsBioavailability problems; trials not very positiveCertaintyhedgedmild caution -
Organic (prompted)
Chandel does not recommend NAD precursors for general geroprotection; NAD levels don't appear rate-limiting in normal aging. Possibly useful for specific conditions like liver regeneration.
“not for geroprotective. I just don't see how
CaveatsFailed in ITP mouse longevity trialsCertaintyexplicitmild caution -
Organic (prompted)
Chandel does not see justification for SS-31 as a general mitochondrial booster; cardiolipin is not rate-limiting in healthy people.
“for you and I, and for most people, I just don't see that
CaveatsTarget/mechanism poorly definedCertaintyexplicitmild caution -
Organic (prompted)
Mechanism intriguing (shuttles electrons bypassing complex I/III) but therapeutic window is narrow due to monoamine oxidase inhibition risk; not endorsed for general use.
“the therapeutic window of that drug is pretty narrow
CaveatsRisk of serotonin toxicity especially with SSRIs via MAO inhibitionCertaintyhedgedmild caution -
Organic (prompted)
Chandel strongly discourages hyperbaric oxygen therapy outside of wound healing; high oxygen causes senescence of lung epithelial cells.
“No, please don't. ... This one is for sure bad.
CaveatsException: wound healing has valid indicationCertaintyexplicitstrong warning -
Organic (prompted)
Chandel acknowledges red light therapy has evidence for skin rejuvenation and possibly glucose uptake; mechanism may involve cytochrome oxidase and H2O2 signaling but unclear.
“clinical trials have definitely shown efficacy for red light... in skin rejuvenation
CaveatsMechanism unclearCertaintyhedgedoffhand mention -
Metformin may lower inflammation via complex I inhibition in alveolar macrophages, potentially reducing IL-6 from air pollution exposure.
“metformin... lowered the IL-6
CaveatsHuman trials not yet done for pollution/inflammation endpointCertaintyspeculativerecommendation